Stop Buying the Wrong Printer: Scenarios for Choosing Between Kodak and Inkjet/Laser

Stop Buying the Wrong Printer: A Guide Based on My (Costly) Mistakes

Look, I have a confession to make. For the first few years handling print procurement for a mid-sized retail and marketing team, I was the guy who just... bought the cheapest printer. I thought I was saving money. I was wrong. Embarrassingly wrong.

The vendor failure in March 2023 changed how I think about printing. One of our Kodak mini photo printers (the Mini 2) died during a critical pop-up event. We didn't have a spare. We had to scramble and buy a crappy consumer-grade inkjet from a local store because we were desperate. (Surprise, surprise: it clogged within two days). That experience made me realize there is no universal "best printer." It depends entirely on your use case.

This guide breaks down the decision into three common business scenarios. I will share specific advice for each, based on my own buying mistakes and the checklist I now use to avoid them.

---

Scenario A: High-Volume Black & White (The Laser Case)

If your team prints hundreds of invoices, reports, or shipping labels daily, you probably need a laser printer. This seems obvious, but I still see people buying cheap inkjets for high-volume office work. Stop that.

What I learned the hard way

In Q1 2024, I ordered 2,000 inkjet cartridges for a new office setup. By the end of the month, 3 of the 8 printers were already showing low ink warnings. The cost of replacement ink alone was going to exceed the cost of the printers within 4 months. (Ugh). I should have just bought a single, solid laser printer from the start.

My recommendation

For pure text and simple graphics, you want a monochrome laser. Look at the cost per page (CPP), not the machine price. A $200 machine with a $0.02 CPP is cheaper than a $50 machine with a $0.15 CPP after just 1,000 pages.

• Best for: Shipping labels (especially with a thermal printer like Kodak's square receipt printer), invoices, internal memos.
• Avoid: Inkjet for high volume. Even the best tank systems have higher maintenance needs.
• Reference: Standard laser toner yield is typically 1,500-3,000 pages for standard cartridges (Source: industry specifications, 2024). Verify current rates.

---

Scenario B: On-Demand Color & Photos (The Kodak Mini Case)

This is where things get interesting. For a long time, I thought you needed a massive, expensive color laser to print good photos. Then I tripped and fell into the world of portable photo printers. (Note to self: be more careful near trade show tables).

What I learned from a $890 mistake

In August 2022, I ordered 500 high-end brochures with printed photos. The job went to a commercial offset printer. The colors were fine. But the process took 11 days and cost a fortune. Later that year, I bought a Kodak Step Instant printer for a single event. It was small, quick, and the quality was... actually good enough for small-instagram prints and proofing. (Happy accident).

The mistake I made was assuming "photo quality" always meant a big machine. It doesn't always. For point-of-sale prints, customer instant pictures, or labeling for small products, a mini photo printer is often the better, cheaper, and faster choice.

My recommendation

If you need color prints in small batches (under 100 at a time), especially for photos or labels, a dye-sublimation printer like the Kodak Mini 2 is a solid option. It's cheaper upfront than a color laser, and the total cost of ownership is often lower if you don't print daily. The ink doesn't dry out like inkjet.

• Best for: Event photography giveaways, product labels (small runs), real estate detail sheets, proofing.
• Avoid: Using it for heavy document printing. The per-page cost for text is higher than a laser.
• Real talk: The Kodak Step's print quality is surprisingly consistent. (I've dropped mine three times and it still works). Small. Light. Survives drops.

---

Scenario C: The All-Rounder Office (Inkjet vs Laser Decoder)

This is the hardest call. You need to print invoices and a color flyer once a month. You see a cheap all-in-one inkjet for $49. You buy it. That was my second biggest mistake.

What I learned

I once ordered 2,000 items (banners and booklets) with a specific Pantone blue. We checked the color on our office's $99 inkjet. It looked fine on screen. The result from the print vendor came back completely wrong. 2,000 items in the trash. $3,200 wasted. Straight to the trash. That's when I learned that office inkjet is great for internal docs but a dangerous liar for color-critical proofing.

I get why people want a simple inkjet laser alternative. But the real question is: what is your main print need? If it is 80% black text and 20% color, you might be better with a cheap monochrome laser for text and a specific photo printer for color. Or, you might want a color laser if you print enough color.

My decision framework (the cheat sheet)

Here's how I now structure this choice. Stop looking at the printer price. Start looking at the cost per page and your volume.

Your need	Best pick	Why
High-volume black text	Monochrome Laser or Thermal	Lowest cost per page, most reliable.
High-volume color documents	Color Laser	Faster than inkjet for mixed use.
Low-volume color photos	Portable photo printer (e.g., Kodak Mini)	Lower upfront cost. No drying ink.
Color + Text (mixed low volume)	Standard Inkjet or Tank Inkjet	Cheapest upfront, but watch the ink costs.

---

The $3,000 Lesson: How to Know Which Scenario YOU Are In

So, how do you figure out if you are Scenario A, B, or C? Don't guess. Do this quick check.

1. Count your pages. How many pages do you print per week? If it is over 500, you are likely Scenario A. If it is under 50, you might be Scenario B or C.
2. Check your color needs. Do you need photos that look like photos? Or just charts? Photos = Scenario B (or a high-end color laser). Charts = cheaper inkjet/laser.
3. Are you printing just labels? If 90% of your printing is receipts or shipping labels, do not buy a general office printer. Buy a thermal label printer (like a square receipt printer). It saves you on expensive ink and paper jams.

Final piece of advice: Good enough is better than perfect. A portable Kodak printer that you use every day is better than a pro-grade laser printer that gathers dust because it is complicated. (Sage advice, I've learned).

This was accurate as of Q1 2025. The printer market changes fast, so verify current pricing and models before you buy. Don't make the same mistakes I did.